You're on a Sunsetters forum. I don't expect anyone here will think you're weird.
And yeah, I can see a certain Radiohead-ness to the title. It sounds like half of a title they'd use on a song on Hail to the Thief.
I couldn't tell what was on it, but he did have a small board at the show I was at. Looked like there were four Boss pedals on it. There was definitely a chorus pedal in the first section of Is This All.
How did I not think of that.
I doubt it's a Tube Screamer. There's too much going on in his tone for it to be just that. My theory is it's some kind of fuzz pedal that's dialed in to a more distortion-esque sound. Maybe a modded Fuzz Face.
I was pretty close to the stage at one of their earlier shows. I'm pretty sure I saw a Rat on Remy's board. And there was a Boss pedal in front of it, but I couldn't quite tell what it was. My best guess is a DS-2, but it might have just looked orange because of the lighting.